Burnt
in. Burnt out.
catalogue
essay for Phip Murray's animation "Brace Brace",
exhibited at BUS, Melbourne & online @ ABC Strange Attractors,
2004
Phip Murray's Brace, Brace is a series of delicate minimal
vignettes based around poetic movements of decorative details:
a woman bleeds, a bomb is dropped, a soldier crawls, rose
petals fall. A soft morbidity is exuded by the restricted
colour palette and the animation's controlled line-work
and graphic veneer. Yet while the work can be appreciated
at surface level for its formal qualities, it is within
that same molecularly compacted surface that its illustrative
purpose be viewed. Brace, Brace stems from a range of Japanese
illustrative techniques, effects and modes which define
the calligraphic nature that arcs across pre- and post-war
Japan.
One
of many documents left by the bombing of Hiroshima in 1945
is the shadows of victims burnt onto walls from the initial
blast of radiation. These are recordings of the most palpable
sort: like Australian indigenous paint splatters formed
by hand-stencils, the shapes of these dead figures are literally
composed by their former selves. Binary distinctions between
abstract and representational have no play in such acts
of encoding. The resulting images are haunting, disquieting
and stilling - not through metaphor but through the fusion
of material and manifestation.
The
calligraphic base of Japanese visual culture results from
similar acts of fusion. The brush strokes of kanji by any
master of the art are less a recourse to expressionism and
more an encoding of electro-magnetic energy channelled through
the body and expelled in a motion gesture of ink on paper.
The kanji character is read as sign but its actuality is
a physical incident whose phenomenological traits determine
its presence and status more than an extant linguistic system.
In
this fundamental collapse between inscripture and mark-making,
the world of Japanese aesthetics takes root and sprawls.
The bulk of its two major trajectories of painting - the
traditional yamato-e and the modern nihonga-e - have been
diagnosed by European sensibilities as 'decorative'. Nothing
could be more appropriate: Japanese painting is about the
cosmic scale of existence that shimmers within the surface
depth of any act of painting. The granular brush stroke
is the utter thinness of the brush's presence on paper;
it operates at the epidermis that bleeds ink into paper's
porous realm, just as it throws us into the universe of
natural chaotic patterning and texturing that occurs when
ink touches paper. Like life under a microscope, Japanese
painting is both declaration of its ephemeral transience
(hence the attraction to nature's seasonal cycles) and statement
of life's complex folding between the ecological and the
philosophical. The fact that the most profound objects of
Japanese 'paintings' are screens, scrolls, kimonos and bowls
adorned with pictorial devices which acknowledge the symbolic
and utilitarian aspects of these objects lends them to be
misinterpreted as celebrations of the decorative.
Japanese
manga (printed comics) and anime (animated films) are largely
treated as 'pictogrammatic' by the same sensibilities which
insist that Japanese painting is decorative. Side-stepping
that limiting perspective can allow one to trace an ongoing
morphology of form and style which links the appended screens
of 17th Century painting to both the sequencing of frames
in manga and the layered dynamics and contrapuntal movements
of anime. Neither of these latter-day story media are aligned
to realism - which moves the blind westerner to ungainly
equate them with the tone and purpose of Disney productions.
And just as yamato-e grew with delicacy from an interplay
with waku (a 31-syllable form of poetry), manga and anime
poetics are infused within their audiovisual momentum. Reading
manga and anime is a complex activity which reflects the
sophisticated approach to form and gesture taken in these
populist forms.
Manga's
post-war approach to accelerated momentum and compressed
dynamism is split between the heady sensual swirls of bishojo
manga (girls' comics) and the heated searing slashes shonen
manga (boys' comics). Gendered symbolism is heightened by
a florid explosion of flowers, stars and jewellery in the
former and a violent expulsion of swords, bullets and fists
in the latter. The line work in manga promotes a hyper-abstraction
of gravitational sway and dimensional wavering as frames
are blurred, blended and broken, which in turn renders the
manga page as a hyper-graphic emotional map. Plot and theme
will be inconsequential compared to the para-baroque excessiveness
of the illustrative detailing. Again, the 'decorative' might
be discerned in manga's splash pages, but the brush work
is a fractal network of dramatic signage 'read' as energy
moving across the page's sequenced frames.
Anime
takes manga's inference of movement and actualises momentum.
In doing so, the balletic denouement which simulates camera
movement recreates the implied subjective viewpoints which
invite one's movement in front of traditional screen paintings
(usually comprised of sets of 6 panels, totalling around
1.5m high to 3 metres wide per set). Rather than subsume
cinematic language into its form, anime returns us to the
greater lineage and traditions of those screens. And true
to Japanese visual aesthetics and scopic articulation, anime
is neither a box trapping life or a window onto the world,
but a screen emblazoned with a poetics of movement.
In
place of the momentous, Japanese storytelling focuses on
the moment. Not unlike the cinematic figure of a passing
train in the distance or a close-up of pouring milk into
a cup of coffee (both archetypes of reflective points in
Japanese cinema and anime) the 'moment' is the space for
reflection. Japanese visual arts extol vistas of emptiness
and nothingness in order to spatially denote and formally
direct the viewer to reflection. These moments can be violently
interrupted by a bold brush stroke (as in traditional calligraphy
scrolls of haiku), a slice of a samurai's sword (as in the
broad chambara genre of swordplay movies made famous by
Akira Kurosawa) or a detonation of an atomic bomb (as per
most cyberpunk anime in the wake of Otomo Katsuhiro's Akira).
Japanese
post-war culture has spent the last half-decade not simply
undergoing yet another wave of 'modernisation' (as described
by many Nippophile commentators in respect of Japan's series
of socio-political shifts from feudal society): it has forged
substantial links with its traditional history of artistic
endeavour. The ideas discussed above which fuse the old
with the new in the arts in Japan are hard to disavow at
the start of a new millennium.
Importing
many of the Japanese sensibilities outlined above, Phip
Murray's Brace Brace stands as a transcultural use of screens,
reconfiguring the gestural, painterly and graphic aspects
of traditional Japanese screen painting into a televisual
form that embraces the poetic movement and cultural iconography
of manga and anime. The simplicity of the animated sequences
foregrounds their gestural status in a way that recalls
the general grace and elegance of much Japanese art. Brace,
Brace's imagery occurs mostly in voids of white, referencing
the aesthetic and purpose screen painting employs to frame
its visual contents. The animation's restricted palette,
flat surfacing and hard-lined contours heighten supposedly
decorative detailing not for ornamentation, but to touch
the deeper symbolic resonance of motifs like clouds, roses,
dresses, blood, planes and mountains.
While
appearing to be poetic and beautiful, Brace, Brace is most
'Japanese' in its modulation of unsettling content with
gentile statement. Elements like the blood that soaks a
dress and the approaching shape of a B-52 bomber inevitably
site the narrative in a voided post-war emotional terrain
typical of that etched into global consciousness by Hiroshima's
aftermath. Brace, Brace's title and its quotation of the
emergency-call to passengers on a plane about to crash suitably
snares our current perspective on inexperienced history
via the intersection of the luxury of international air-travel
and the nearest we might get to a true ground zero.